↓ Skip to main content
tomrochette.com
  1. Agents/
  2. Protocols/

Protocols Feature Matrix

Author
glm-5.3, glm-5.3-flash
History / Edit / PDF / EPUB / MD
Created: / Updated: / Status: finished / Readability: 3 / 22 minutes read (~4266 words)
agent-curated 572 comparison 24 fully-ai-generated 675 interoperability 7 llm=glm-5.3 169 llm=glm-5.3-flash 582 protocols 15
Table of Contents

This matrix compares the thirteen protocols profiled in this section, A2A, A2UI, ACP, AG-UI, Agent Host Protocol, Agent Protocol (LangChain), AGENTS.md, ANP, llms.txt, MCP, PIC Standard, Unified Harness Protocol (UHP), and WebMCP, so the whole interoperability stack can be read in one table.

The thirteen do not compete, they stack (repo-to-agent, editor-to-agent, agent-to-frontend, agent-to-tool, agent-to-agent, client-to-session, app-to-agent serving, open-web identity and discovery, site content discovery, UI payload, browser tool exposure, tool-call verification), and adoption falls with every step up that stack, which is why I call AGENTS.md and MCP defaults, ACP a rising bet, AG-UI the quiet winner by raw download volume, AHP a bet underwritten by VS Code’s own distribution, A2UI the payload format the frontend layer is converging on, the Agent Protocol the serving API waiting for a second implementation, UHP the Responses-compatible draft claiming the harness side of that same serving lane, PIC Standard the fail-closed verification gate at the tool boundary, llms.txt the docs-side convention search refuses to honor, WebMCP the browser bet only one browser ships, A2A an enterprise convention the coding-agent world can keep ignoring, and ANP the decentralized open-web bet the market has not bought yet.

Legend: ✓ supported, ✗ not supported, ~ partial or conditional, ? not verified. Each column links to the full research note; every cell below traces to a source cited there or in the references.

The matrix
#

Feature A2A A2UI ACP AG-UI Agent Host Protocol Agent Protocol (LangChain) AGENTS.md ANP llms.txt MCP PIC Standard Unified Harness Protocol (UHP) WebMCP
Kind wire protocol declarative UI payload format wire protocol wire protocol wire protocol REST/OpenAPI serving spec file convention wire protocol suite file convention wire protocol verification protocol (pre-execution action gating) HTTP serving spec browser API standard
Originated by Google (2025-04) Google (2025-12) Zed, with JetBrains CopilotKit (2025-05) Microsoft (2026-03) LangChain (2024-11) OpenAI-led (2025-08) community working group (2024-10) Jeremy Howard, Answer.AI (2024-09) Anthropic (2024-11) pic-standard project, RFC-0001 defensive publication (2026-01) HarnessRouter (2026-08) Microsoft and Google engineers, W3C Web ML CG (2026-02)
Steward AAIF (2026-08), TSC Google, a2ui-project org, no foundation vendor-neutral org CopilotKit, no foundation Microsoft, no foundation LangChain, no foundation AAIF community working group, no foundation Answer.AI author-driven, no foundation AAIF project org, no foundation, a public call for co-maintainers open HarnessRouter, no foundation (maintainer-led UEP process) W3C Web Machine Learning Community Group
Spec license Apache-2.0 Apache-2.0 Apache-2.0 MIT MIT MIT MIT Apache-2.0 none stated MIT Apache-2.0 Apache-2.0 W3C CG terms
Maturity v1.0.1 (2026-05) v0.9.1 production, v1.0 release candidate version 1, v2 draft, remote WIP packages 1.0.3 (2026-10-16), spec 1.0 v1.0.0 (2026-10-02) OpenAPI 0.1.6, active unversioned, de facto standard specs 1.2 latest (1.0, 1.1 archived), two drafts open v2 (2026-08), v1 (2024-09) dated revisions (2026-07-28) v0.9.1 (2026-10-14), pre-1.0; RFC-0001 anchored for v0.1.0 to v0.5.5, Canonical JSON v1 frozen, PIC-Core and PIC-Evidence drafts normative only at v1.0 draft standard 2026-10-19 (fifth version since 2026-08) CG draft (2026-10-20), Chrome origin trial 149 to 156
What it connects agent-to-agent agent-to-frontend UI payload editor-to-agent agent-to-frontend client-to-session app-to-agent serving repo-to-agent agent-to-agent, open-web site-to-agent content discovery app-to-tools action proposal to verifier (agent-to-tool-call gating) app-to-harness serving site-to-agent tool exposure
Adoption in this section ~ via the official CLI and skill (2026-10-01), none native ✗ none native (carried by AG-UI and A2A transports) ~ growing (OpenCode, JetBrains, Zed) ✗ none native (CopilotKit ecosystem outside this index) ~ VS Code reference host ✗ none native (LangChain ecosystem only) ~ most; Claude Code shipped native support 2026-09-18 ✗ none native (MCP bridge exists) ~ docs surfaces in this index serve it; required by none ✓ near-universal ✗ none native (an MCP guard integration is documented) ✗ none native (harnesses are the driven party) ✗ none native (browser lane outside this index)
Transport or location HTTP, gRPC, JSON-RPC streaming JSONL component list over A2A or AG-UI JSON-RPC over stdio SSE, WebSockets, webhooks URI channels on a standalone sessions server REST over HTTPS, runs, threads, and agents endpoints Markdown at repo root HTTPS, DID documents, messaging profiles Markdown at site or path root, HTTP Link headers JSON-RPC, stdio to sse signed JSON Action Proposals verified locally by CLI, library, or MCP guard; no wire transport of its own HTTPS, SSE streaming, Responses-compatible request body document.modelContext browser API, no wire transport
Official SDKs ✓ six ✓ Lit, Angular, Flutter, and Markdown renderers, Python and TS packages ✓ five ✓ three first-party, seven community ✓ six ✓ Python server stubs and TS bindings ✗ none needed ~ community SDKs and an MCP bridge ✓ Python and JavaScript tooling, community generators ✓ any language ✓ Python reference (pic-standard on PyPI) and a TypeScript verifier passing the shared conformance corpus; Go and Rust planned ~ OpenAPI 3.1 schema plus a runnable conformance suite, no first-party SDKs ✗ none needed (web platform API)
Criticism recorded redundant with MCP spec churn, Google stewardship, injection through generated UI sprawl, flattened UX single-vendor origin, pre-1.0 churn more sprawl, one vendor’s governance one company stewards spec and commercial superset, missing community footprint, name collision with the 2023 spec weak efficacy evidence near-zero adoption, complexity search engines ignore it, author-driven governance, adjacent conventions fragment tool poisoning, supply chain thin footprint (69 stars, a 1-point Show HN, 697 PyPI downloads a month), pre-1.0 churn, v0.9.0 broke conformant semi_trusted emitters five spec versions in ten weeks, one vendor’s repo-first governance, thin community footprint one browser ships it, mid-year API rename and October removal of the declarative path, open security risks

Reading the matrix
#

Governance converged faster than adoption, and every protocol that went neutral did so only after it had already won or stalled. Google donated A2A to the Linux Foundation in June 2025, Anthropic and OpenAI donated MCP and AGENTS.md to the AAIF the same day (2025-12-09), and A2A itself joined the AAIF as a Growth Stage project on 2026-08-27, so three of the thirteen now sit in the same foundation. ACP is stewarded by Zed and JetBrains under a vendor-neutral organization with no foundation home, AHP stays inside the microsoft org with repo-first governance, AG-UI remains closest to its corporate parent, CopilotKit, which also sells commercial support for it, ANP has no governance above its working group, the Agent Protocol is stewarded by the same LangChain that sells its commercial superset, UHP is maintained in the HarnessRouter repository under the maintainer’s own UEP process while the same vendor sells the hosted implementation, llms.txt remains author-driven at Answer.AI with no conformance process, and A2UI stays with Google’s a2ui-project organization, while WebMCP is the one newer column with a neutral home in the W3C Community Group process, and PIC stays with its project organization and a public call for co-maintainers, so the stack now has nine non-foundation columns, and ACP remains the one compounding fastest in editors. I read this as governance following adoption, not causing it.

Adoption falls as the protocol climbs the stack, and the file convention beat every wire protocol to default status. MCP is table stakes across the harness and surface matrices; AGENTS.md counts more than 60,000 carrying projects, and its one glaring holdout closed on 2026-09-18 when Claude Code shipped native support in 2.1.277; ACP rides OpenCode, JetBrains, Zed, and a Copilot CLI preview; A2A has no native speaker among this index’s harnesses, only community setups near Gemini CLI plus the official CLI and agent skill the project shipped on 2026-10-01; AHP is just over six months old with 400 stars and a fresh 1.0.0 spec (2026-10-02) as of 2026-10-13, and its reference host ships inside VS Code while the VS Code team has said publicly it is rebuilding its agent infrastructure on the protocol. The SDK download ratio recorded in the A2A note, about 11.4M monthly versus about 235M for MCP as of 2026-10-07, is the gap in one number, and AHP’s roughly 940k combined downloads (about 322.3k crates plus 617.3k npm, as of 2026-10-24) show the same order-of-magnitude distance from the top. The Agent Protocol sits with the young serving specs: 687 stars, active through 2026-10-13, with LangGraph Platform as its one commercial implementation and no independent adopter in this index. UHP is the newest serving bet: the spec ships inside HarnessRouter’s 2,994-star repository (as of 2026-10-13), the hosted service and SuperQode’s 62-star framework are the recorded implementations, and its discussion footprint is one 10-point Show HN thread with zero stories naming the protocol itself. PIC Standard sits below even UHP on reach while overmatching it on specification form: 69 stars, a 1-point Show HN, and 697 PyPI downloads in the month ending 2026-10-10, against an anchored RFC, a frozen canonicalization spec, a 91-vector conformance corpus, and a second implementation passing it, with differential CI keeping the two verifiers aligned. llms.txt splits the file-convention lane with AGENTS.md: thousands of sites and the docs of tools in this index serve it (Anthropic’s and OpenAI’s developer docs confirmed live this run), coding agents fetch it, and the search crawlers its SEO adopters hoped for still ignore it. AG-UI is the anomaly that proves the rule: none of this index’s harnesses or surfaces speak it natively, yet its SDKs moved about 15.1M combined npm downloads in the month ending 2026-10-22, because the frontend layer is where end-user products live even though coding tools never touch it. A2UI is the newest layer to fill in: launched in December 2025, it passed 16,600 stars in ten months and is carried by Google’s own Opal and Gemini Enterprise plus Flutter’s GenUI SDK, adoption that outruns its release-candidate spec. WebMCP sits at the browser edge: 4,621 stars, a Chrome origin trial, and Shopify and Cloudflare turning it default-on across much of commerce in August 2026, while Gemini in Chrome remains the only agent consuming those tools at scale. ANP sits below even A2A: 1.4k stars after two years and Hacker News stories at 2 and 1 points are the footprint of a protocol whose network effect has not started.

The consolidations the notes record happened in opposite corners, and neither touched the other’s territory. IBM’s Agent Communication Protocol (the other ACP, the source of the name collision) merged into A2A in August 2025 under LF AI and Data. JetBrains folded its internal Junie protocol into the Agent Client Protocol instead. Both mergers cut the rival count in 2025 while leaving the enterprise-remote and local-editor layers separate.

Each recorded criticism is a different species of doubt, and the pattern favors the incumbents. MCP is criticized for risks it creates (tool poisoning, rug pulls, a 10,000-server supply chain); AGENTS.md for whether it helps at all (an ETH Zurich study found no success-rate gain and over 20% added inference cost, against Vercel’s counter-evidence); ACP for UX flattening and protocol sprawl; AHP for being a fifth protocol to track under one vendor’s governance; A2A for whether it should exist at all; AG-UI for provenance and maturity, a CopilotKit-originated stack that only graduated to 1.0.0 packages on 2026-09-17 and whose adoption story lives in vendor blogs; A2UI for spec churn and Google stewardship, four versions in under a year with no foundation home; WebMCP for shipping in one browser under a draft that renamed its central API mid-year; ANP for building infrastructure for a network that does not exist yet; the Agent Protocol for a community footprint that has not started and one company holding both spec and commercial superset; UHP for five versions in ten weeks under the stewarding vendor’s own repository; PIC for a footprint that has not started, a breaking v0.9.0, and a binding that only holds callers that opt in; and llms.txt for being ignored by the search crawlers its SEO adopters expected and governed by nobody but its author. The mature protocols get attacked for their risks, the young ones for their reason to exist or their provenance.

Choosing from the matrix
#

  • Exposing tools or data to any agent: MCP, the default with a supply-chain asterisk.
  • Choosing harness and editor independently: ACP, the cheapest portability insurance in the stack.
  • Streaming an agent into a product frontend: AG-UI, accepting CopilotKit’s stewardship and dated-release churn (1.0.0 only landed 2026-09-17).
  • Rendering agent-generated UI natively and safely in your own product: A2UI, pinned to v0.9.1 until the v1.0 candidate lands.
  • Making a public website’s features callable by browser agents: WebMCP, accepting Chrome-only reach and draft-status churn today.
  • Serving your own agents behind a conventional runs-and-threads API: the Agent Protocol, accepting LangChain stewardship and a thin adopter base.
  • Driving complete coding-agent harnesses from your own product over HTTP: UHP, accepting draft-version churn and HarnessRouter stewardship while the conformance suite keeps implementations verifiable.
  • Gating high-impact tool calls on verifiable provenance and evidence: PIC Standard, accepting pre-1.0 status, churn, and the fact that frameworks must opt in to the verifier.
  • Making a docs surface readable by agents: publish llms.txt with the v2 link headers, and expect nothing from search crawlers.
  • Any repository an agent touches: commit a short AGENTS.md, commands and conventions first.
  • Delegating work across vendors or departments: A2A, provided both sides run enterprise platforms.
  • Betting on open-web agent discovery before platforms mediate everything: ANP, as a research bet, not a production choice.
  • Attaching a second client to a live agent session: AHP, provided v1.0.0’s short track record and Microsoft’s stewardship are acceptable.
  • Wiring sub-agents inside one framework: none of these, native primitives or MCP are simpler.

Changes
#

  • 2026-08-24 - Created with the stacking thesis and recorded protocol consolidations.
  • 2026-09-16 - Extended from five to six columns with AG-UI, re-sorted alphabetically, and updated the governance, adoption, criticism, and choosing prose for the agent-to-frontend layer.
  • 2026-09-18 - AG-UI maturity cell updated to 1.0.0 packages and a published 1.0 specification, and stars and download figures refreshed in the AG-UI and AHP prose.
  • 2026-09-21 - AGENTS.md adoption cell updated after Claude Code shipped native support in 2.1.277 (2026-09-18), ending the holdout the cell recorded; AG-UI and AHP download and star figures refreshed in the prose.
  • 2026-09-24 - Removed the verification preamble line on owner request.
  • 2026-09-24 - Re-verification: refreshed star and download figures in the AG-UI and AHP prose (AG-UI about 12.0M combined monthly downloads, AHP 363 stars and roughly 369k combined downloads).
  • 2026-09-25 - Re-sorted the columns by member title (ACP and Agent Host Protocol precede A2A under the case-insensitive title ordering the other matrices use); no cell content changed.
  • 2026-09-27 - Re-verification: refreshed the AG-UI and AHP figures in the prose (AG-UI about 12.9M combined monthly downloads, AHP 368 stars and roughly 410k combined downloads); no cells changed.
  • 2026-09-29 - Re-verification: refreshed the AG-UI and AHP figures in the prose (AG-UI about 12.3M combined monthly downloads, AHP 375 stars and roughly 433k combined downloads); no cells changed.
  • 2026-09-29 - Re-sorted the columns to the section-wide case-insensitive title sort (A2A, ACP, AG-UI, Agent Host Protocol, AGENTS.md, MCP), correcting the 2026-09-25 arrangement that had placed ACP and Agent Host Protocol ahead of A2A and AG-UI; the category page list was brought to the same order in the same run; no cell content changed.
  • 2026-10-02 - Re-verification: refreshed the AG-UI and AHP figures in the prose (AG-UI about 13.1M combined monthly downloads, AHP 382 stars and roughly 597k combined downloads); no cells changed.
  • 2026-10-03 - AHP maturity cell moved to v1.0.0 (2026-10-02) and the AG-UI maturity cell to packages 1.0.1 (2026-09-29), with star and download figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 14.6M combined monthly downloads, AHP 384 stars and roughly 681k combined downloads).
  • 2026-10-05 - Extended from six to seven columns with ANP (the community DID-based agent-interop suite), inserted in sorted position between AGENTS.md and MCP and traced to the new note; the intro, reading, and choosing sections updated for the seventh protocol; AG-UI and AHP figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 15.0M combined monthly downloads, AHP 386 stars and roughly 733k combined downloads).
  • 2026-10-06 - Extended from seven to nine columns with A2UI (Google’s declarative generative-UI payload format) and WebMCP (the W3C browser tool-exposure draft), inserted in sorted positions and traced to the new notes; the A2A adoption cell moved to record the official CLI and agent skill (2026-10-01) and the AG-UI maturity cell to packages 1.0.2 (2026-10-05); the intro, governance, adoption, criticism, and choosing sections updated for the two new protocols; AG-UI and AHP figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 14.8M combined monthly downloads, AHP 390 stars and roughly 823k combined downloads).
  • 2026-10-07 - Extended from nine to eleven columns with Agent Protocol (LangChain) (the REST/OpenAPI serving spec) and llms.txt (the site-content-discovery convention, now at v2), inserted in sorted positions and traced to the new notes; the AHP figures in the prose refreshed to 392 stars and roughly 848k combined downloads, the A2A-versus-MCP download ratio to about 11.4M versus about 235M as of 2026-10-07, and the WebMCP star count to 4,478; the intro, governance, adoption, criticism, and choosing sections updated for the two new members.
  • 2026-10-08 - Extended from eleven to twelve columns with Unified Harness Protocol (UHP) (the Responses-compatible harness-serving draft), inserted in sorted position between MCP and WebMCP and traced to the new note; the intro, governance, adoption, criticism, and choosing sections updated for the twelfth protocol; figures refreshed in the prose (AHP 392 stars and roughly 852k combined downloads, the Agent Protocol active through 2026-10-07, WebMCP 4,487 stars).
  • 2026-10-09 - Re-sorted the columns alphabetically by member title, case-insensitive, moving A2A from the founding first position to its title-sorted place; no cell content changed.
  • 2026-10-09 - WebMCP’s maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-08 and its criticism cell records the same-day removal of the declarative path; the intro’s protocol-name list was brought to the column order and its eleven count corrected to twelve; figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 15.9M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-07, AHP 396 stars and roughly 878k combined downloads, WebMCP 4,499 stars, HarnessRouter 2,941 stars); no membership change.
  • 2026-10-10 - Figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 16.8M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-08, AHP 398 stars and roughly 904k combined downloads, WebMCP 4,515 stars, HarnessRouter 2,951 stars); the WebMCP maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-09 (an editorial pass on top of the 10-08 declarative removal) and the A2UI SDKs cell records the Markdown renderer; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-11 - Extended from twelve to thirteen columns with PIC Standard (the Apache-2.0 pre-execution action-gating protocol with an anchored RFC, a conformance corpus, and a TypeScript verifier passing it), inserted alphabetically between MCP and Unified Harness Protocol (UHP), every row gaining a cell traced to the new note; the stack thesis, governance counts, adoption, and criticism paragraphs updated, and the choosing section gained a PIC bullet.
  • 2026-10-11 - Re-verification: refreshed the prose figures (AG-UI about 16.9M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-09, AHP roughly 921k combined downloads, WebMCP 4,535 stars, HarnessRouter 2,959 stars); the A2A-versus-MCP download ratio, the UHP fourth-version draft, the A2UI v1.0 candidate, the llms.txt and MCP spec revisions, the AG-UI 1.0.2 packages, and the ACP SDK train all re-verified unchanged; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-13 - Re-verification: the intro’s protocol-name list still said twelve and omitted PIC Standard after the 2026-10-11 extension, so the count moved to thirteen and the list was brought to column order; the misplaced 2026-10-11 extension bullet returned to its date order; every maturity cell re-verified against live sources (A2A v1.0.1, A2UI v0.9.1 production plus the v1.0 candidate, ACP SDKs at 3.3.0 and 1.8.0, AG-UI packages 1.0.2, AHP v1.0.0, Agent Protocol OpenAPI 0.1.6, ANP 1.2, llms.txt v2, MCP revision 2026-07-28, PIC v0.9.0, UHP 2026-10-04 as its fourth version, WebMCP draft 2026-10-09) and no cell changed.
  • 2026-10-13 - Re-verification: WebMCP’s maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-13 (algorithm fixes to the concurrency, detached-document, and permissions checks, no API surface change) and the PIC criticism cell’s star figure moved to 69; volatile figures refreshed in the prose (AG-UI about 17.0M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-12, AHP 400 stars and roughly 951k combined downloads, WebMCP 4,621 stars, HarnessRouter 2,994 stars, the Agent Protocol 687 stars); no membership change.
  • 2026-10-16 - The PIC maturity cell moved to v0.9.1 (2026-10-14), which completed tool-argument binding at the MCP guard and bridge boundary and grew the conformance corpus from 84 to 91 vectors with the wire format unchanged; the WebMCP maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-15 (two more algorithm-level fixes, no API surface change); no membership change.
  • 2026-10-17 - Re-verification: the WebMCP maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-16 (an editorial explainer sync, no API surface change), and the MCP revision (2026-07-28), the UHP draft (2026-10-04), the ANP 1.2 suite, the PIC v0.9.1 release, and the A2A v1.0.1 release all re-verified unchanged; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-18 - Re-verification: the AG-UI prose figure refreshed to about 16.3M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-16, the UHP implementing product’s release train recorded at v0.35.1 (2026-10-18) with its draft unchanged at 2026-10-04, and the MCP revision (2026-07-28), the WebMCP draft (2026-10-16), the ANP 1.2 suite, the Agent Protocol OpenAPI 0.1.6, the AG-UI 1.0.3 packages, and the PIC v0.9.1 release re-verified unchanged; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-20 - Re-verification: the UHP maturity cell moved to the 2026-10-19 fifth version and its criticism cell and the adoption prose moved to five versions in ten weeks, the AG-UI prose figure refreshed to about 15.9M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-18, and the A2A v1.0.1 release, the A2UI v0.9.1-plus-candidate table, the ACP v1 protocol with the TypeScript SDK’s breaking 2.0.0, the MCP revision (2026-07-28), the PIC v0.9.1 release, the ANP 1.2 suite, and the Agent Protocol OpenAPI 0.1.6 re-verified unchanged; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-22 - Re-verification: the WebMCP maturity cell moved to the draft revision of 2026-10-20 (an agent-ecosystem-risks discussion and a new editor, no API surface change) and the AG-UI maturity cell caught up to the packages 1.0.3 (2026-10-16) its note already recorded; the A2A v1.0.1 release, the A2UI v0.9.1-plus-candidate table, the ACP releases (v1.12.0 / schema-v1.26.0), the MCP revision (2026-07-28), the AHP v1.0.0 tags, the ANP 1.2 suite, the Agent Protocol OpenAPI 0.1.6, the PIC v0.9.1 release, and the UHP 2026-10-19 fifth version all re-verified unchanged; no membership change.
  • 2026-10-24 - Re-verification: the AG-UI prose figure refreshed to about 15.1M combined downloads in the month ending 2026-10-22 and the AHP prose figures to roughly 940k combined downloads (crate 322,294 lifetime plus npm 617,300 for 2026-09-24 to 2026-10-23); the ACP SDK train moved to Rust 3.5.0 and TypeScript 2.0.2 with its agents list at 46, the UHP implementing product’s train to v0.36.3 with the spec unchanged, the A2A v1.0.1 release, the A2UI v0.9.1-plus-candidate table, the MCP revision (2026-07-28), and the ANP v1.2 release train all re-verified unchanged; no membership change.

See also
#

References
#